Partnering with the Best Insurance Companies Serving South Carolina

At Tidwell Agency in Lexington, we work with some of the finest companies available here in South Carolina and nationwide for quotes and service in all lines of insurance, including home, auto, health, life and business insurance. As independent agents, we are able to offer coverage to you from any combination of these carriers, depending upon the type of insurance you are seeking.

Our insurance companies include:

Accident Fund

Customer Service & Claims: 866-206-5851
Website: https://www.accidentfund.com

Amerisafe

Claims: 800-699-6240
Customer Service: 800-897-9719
Accounting: 800-256-9052
Website: https://www.amerisafe.com

Auto-Owners Insurance

Claims – After Hours: 888-252-4626
Claims – Regular Hours: 517-323-1200
Customer Service: 800-288-8740
Website: https://www.auto-owners.com

Blue Cross Blue Shield Association

Claims & Customer Service Website: http://www.bcbs.com/contact-us
Website: https://www.southcarolinablues.com

EMC Insurance

Claims: 1-888-362-2255
Customer Service: 800-333-3622
Website: https://www.emcins.com

Foremost Insurance Group

Claims: 800-527-3907
Customer Service: 800-527-3905
Billing – Auto: 888-888-0080
Billing – Other: 800-532-4221
Website: https://www.foremost.com

Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company

Claims and Billing: 888-884-2424
Customer Service: 800-558-6411
Website: https://www.jewelersmutual.com

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Claims: 800-561-0178
Customer Service: 877-566-6001
Billing: 877-675-4411
Website: https://www.libertymutualgroup.com

Markel - FirstComp

Claims and Customer Service: 888-500-3344
Website: https://www.firstcomp.com

Progressive

Claims & Customer Service: 800-776-4737
Billing: 800-PROGRESSIVE
Website: www.progressive.com

Safeco Insurance

Claims: 800-332-3226
Customer Service: 800-332-3226
Billing: 888-723-3260
Website: https://www.stateauto.com

Southern Mutual Church Insurance Company

Claims: 800-922-5332
Customer Service:800-922-5332
Website: https://www.smcins.com

Southern Trust

Customer Service & Claims: 844-812-2660
Website: https://www.stins.com

State Auto Insurance Companies

Claims: 800-766-1853
Website: https://www.stateauto.com

The Hartford

Claims: 800-243-5860
Customer Service: 860-547-5000
Website: https://www.thehartford.com

Travelers

Claims: 800-252-4633
Customer Service: 866-336-2077
Billing: 800-842-5075
Website: https://www.travelers.com

Utica National Insurance Group

Claims – Workers Compensation: 800-284-3806
Claims – Other: 800-216-1420
Customer Service: 800-289-3375
Billing: 800-598-8422
Website: https://www.uticanational.com

Contact Us

Contact Us

Get Your Instant Quote Now

Want a quote for your auto, property or bundled policy? Click below to get your instant quote from Tidwell Agency!

You see insurance ads all the time that say things like “come here, we’ll save you money!” Well, sometimes they can, sometimes they can’t. For our family, one meeting with the Tidwell Agency helped us save hundreds on our homeowners and our auto insurance. Chris was extremely helpful in finding a policy that fit our family….even with teenage drivers! I highly recommend this agency!

John Owens, Columbia, SC